Interview with CTI's Chairman
David Siever:
CTI has nearly a perfect closing record on
competitively-bid financings and asset sales. To understand what accounts for
this, let's walk through the five stages of a typical transaction:
- Assessing the client's objectives
- Preparing a comprehensive cash projection
and/or valuation
- Packaging the opportunity to appeal to prospective
lenders or investors
- Running a tightly-managed bid process
- Actively assisting the parties during due diligence and
documentation.
Problem assessment
The starting point is one or more meetings to
define what the client wants to accomplish, with CTI offering suggestions
regarding what we believe can be achieved under current
market conditions. The end product is a detailed proposal covering mutually agreed objectives,
tasks,
end products, timing and compensation. There's never any charge to
prepare the proposal -- the object is to achieve a meeting of the minds.
Valuation
Before CTI approaches lenders or investors it
always prepares a detailed projection of the cash generation potential of the
project or portfolio of projects in question, starting with an in-depth
analysis of those factors having the biggest impact. CTI often draws on
the experience of its Alliance members as it works with the client's staff,
knowing that solid research and analysis will pay off in the best possible
market reception.
If a debt placement, financing alternatives are
tailored to the cash flow pattern. If a project or asset sale, the
resulting cash flows are valued over the range of discount rates applicable
for investors who are targeting that particular technology. The end product
is a picture of what the client can reasonably expect to receive
in the current market. Since CTI maintains close relationships with a
wide range of "clean" and renewable energy project lenders and
investors, this assessment is usually very accurate.
It's not unusual for CTI to uncover
opportunities for improvement as it prepares the cash flow projection. Conversely,
CTI always brings to the client's attention any strategic flaws
or unusual risks that could impact financeability or impair value. One
of the reasons CTI charges a non-contingent fee during the financial
plan/valuation stage is that it removes any possible incentive to encourage the
client to press ahead to the marketing phase if the asset in question isn't
fully ready to be presented to lenders or investors. Similarly, since
CTI isn't aligned with any particular lender or investor it can be totally
objective in recommending which financial institutions to include and in
working with the client to pick the eye out of the market.
It usually takes CTI two to three weeks to
prepare the financial plan or valuation, after which the client
can move forward
to the packaging/offering stage with confidence that the full range of possible
outcomes has been examined. If the client chooses to stop at this stage,
CTI charges only for the time expended up to that point.
Packaging
One of the ways CTI ensures that an offering
will hit the mark is to mail investors a
short marketing letter summarizing the opportunity well in advance of their
receiving the information memorandum. The feedback gained is often
invaluable for uncovering which features are the most appealing, enabling CTI
to tailor the information memorandum accordingly. Given the experience and sophistication of today's
institutional investors, the need to exercise extra care during the
packaging stage can't be overemphasized.
Most lenders and investors will tell you they
rarely receive tightly-organized offering materials prepared with their needs
in mind. As a former principal, CTI knows what lenders and investors
want to see. As a result, CTI frequently hears from lenders and
investors that its offering materials are among the clearest and most
insightful they have received. Often they will incorporate portions of CTI's memorandum in their
credit committee presentation. We believe strongly that taking the time
to do it right is important to getting investors excited about the opportunity
and committed to closing on attractive terms. After 15 years in
business, this depth of analysis and attention to detail remains one of the
main factors differentiating CTI from its competition.
In contrast to the practice of many of the
larger investment banks, CTI slightly understates the proposal's features at this
stage. While this might seem counter-intuitive, CTI has learned that
creating an increasingly positive experience for the investor is vitally
important to building the confidence and momentum that results in aggressive
bids. The power of the competitive bid process to let the price seek its
maximum supportable level takes care of the rest.
Bid management
During the bid stage the emphasis shifts to a
pure transactions mode. Regardless of the
bid guidelines presented in the information memorandum, every lender or investor moves at
a different pace. Taking the time to respond to bidder's questions
during this critical phase is important to keeping them informed and moving
forward at a brisk pace. For better or for worse, this is when the
bidder's proposed terms get set. Since many bidders will try to test the
advisor, it's important to have been around the track a few times to be able
to recognize their behavior patterns. CTI's main job during this stage is to ensure rapid convergence toward definitive
offers.
Finally, CTI assists the client to pick the one
company appearing best able to go the distance to a successful closing and
keeps one or two others interested and available if needed.
Due diligence and
documentation
Working with the client to prepare the data
room usually begins immediately upon mailing the information memorandum.
Since uncovering a previously undisclosed risk can
be fatal, full disclosure from the outset of anything that might derail closing is
mandatory.
Negotiation of final terms/documentation
CTI always includes a draft term sheet in the
information memorandum and stands by to assist the parties as they negotiate detailed deal
terms. This is a natural role for CTI given its experience on both the
buy and sell side. CTI appreciates what an effective intermediary can do
to bring about agreement during this final stage and stands ready to assume
whatever degree of negotiating involvement the client requires.
Typically, CTI is asked to remain an active participant
throughout the negotiation and documentation phases to guide the parties through the inevitable
rough spots.
In summary
CTI's concentrated participation is important
at all five stages to ensure that your company's offering receives the strongest
possible lender or investor interest. At the first stage, rigorous
analysis enables CTI to uncover hidden attributes. At the second stage,
all our efforts are directed at highlighting these for lenders and
investors. At the third and fourth stages, experience
at running bids enables CTI to anticipate investor' questions and build trust
during due diligence. In the fifth and final stage our long experience at negotiations and documentation can cut weeks or months off the
time to close.
In conclusion, CTI excels at managing the dynamics
of the bid process from start to finish. With the client's close
involvement, the end result is a superior sale price or financing package.

Tough
Assignments, Creative Solutions
Member, National
Association of Securities Dealers (NASD) and the Securities Investor
Protection Corporation (SIPC)